Are you looking for holiday pies in Columbia, SC? Whether you need a delicious dessert for your holiday gathering or just want a scrumptious slice as a special treat for yourself, you can find the perfect pie at these local bakeries.
Many of the bakeries below sell pies throughout the year but take special preorders for holidays and special events. Reach out to them through their contact information before heading to their shop to ensure they have the pie you need!
Bakeries That Sell Pie Near Columbia, SC
New! Save the bakeries that you’re interested in and have your custom list emailed to you.
Kaminsky’s Dessert Cafe
930 Gervais Street, Columbia | 803.550.9979
If you are looking to purchase a whole pie or by the slice, then the pie selection at Kaminsky’s Dessert Cafe is just what you need. Whole 12-inch pies start at $30 each, and there are currently several options on the menu. You can order classic pies like apple and coconut cream in addition to more decadent options like key lime and tollhouse pie. If you are in need of a holiday pie, bourbon pecan may be the perfect fit. You can preorder for pick up, or head into the shop for a slice of your favorite pie for $8. Preorders require a 48-hour notice.
Main Street Bakery & Gift Shop
3307 North Main Street, Columbia | 803.563.5009
This small, family-owned bakery sells lots of delicious treats, including pie! Main Street Bakery’s Thanksgiving pre-order form lists three pies: sweet potato and coconut ($17 each) and pecan ($25). Place your order through the bakery’s Thanksgiving 2026 pre-order page. All Thanksgiving orders must be in by Saturday, November 14, 2026 at 5 pm. Pickup is only on Tuesday, November 24 (10 am–5 pm) and Wednesday, November 25 (10 am–noon). For the rest of the year, you can order from their online ordering system.
Silver Spoon Bake Shop
2507 Devine Street, Columbia | 803.673.6374
Silver Spoon offers tons of baked goods that are sure to make your holidays extra sweet. They post weekly pre-order menus on Wednesdays at 8 pm. Pickup is on Friday from 3 pm-6 pm. Be sure to check their Facebook or Instagram about special Thanksgiving orders and hours.
McCutchen House Dining
902 Sumter Street, Columbia | Purchase a pie
Every November, the University of South Carolina’s School of Hospitality and Tourism Management annually hosts Pie Day. Students perfectly bake hundreds of McCutchen House Chocolate Walnut Pies or Tomato Pie Kits to sell to the public for their holiday feasts. For 2026, pies can be picked up on Friday, November 20th, Monday, November 23rd, or Tuesday, November 24th, from 11:30 am to 1:30 pm under the canopy in the McCutchen House parking lot. The pies have to be preordered through a form, and you must bring your email confirmation as your receipt to pick them up. All pies are handmade, and can even be frozen if you want to buy multiple ones to enjoy later. Chocolate Walnut Pies are $13 each and Tomato Pie Kits are $15 each, plus tax.
Ally & Eloise Bakeshop
2833 Devine Street, Columbia | 5209 Forest Drive, Columbia
Ally & Eloise is a local bakeshop with two Columbia locations, and its online shop includes homemade holiday pies. Current options include Alberta’s Pecan Pie, a Bourbon Apple Pie, and Luby’s Pumpkin Pie, each $40. For a bigger spread, the Thanksgiving Pie & Cake Bundle ($95) pairs a holiday pie with one of their signature cakes. Check the online shop for pickup dates and order deadlines.]
Before you keep scrolling...
Want more ideas like this?
Spend less time searching and get fresh family-fun ideas in your inbox.
Twisted Whisk
206 West Main Street, Lexington
Twisted Whisk offers a fall menu with cakes, pies, cheesecakes, and more! Checkout their website to get all the yummy details!
Here’s where you can find Thanksgiving Restaurants in Columbia, plus places to pick up some sides or dishes to add to your holiday table.
What else do you need to celebrate the holidays in Columbia?
Check out our Ultimate Holiday Guide to Columbia, SC to find everything you need for a wonder-filled holiday season with your family!
Do you know of an excellent pie baker in Columbia? Let us know in the comments!
Before you keep scrolling...
Want more ideas like this?
Spend less time searching and get fresh family-fun ideas in your inbox.